Weeks before this year’s midterm elections, federal officials shared big news: Dozens of noncitizens living in North Carolina were arrested and indicted on charges of voting illegally.

The 30 people charged came from across the world, from Argentina to Italy to Jamaica, according to the federal government. Some were accused of casting ballots as far back as the early 2000s, others as recently as 2024. A press release announcing the first round of indictments included pictures of FBI and Immigration and Customs Enforcement agents posing with handcuffed suspects, the agents’ backs turned to the camera, the suspects’ faces blurred out.

“If you vote illegally, we are looking, we will find out and we will prosecute you,” Ellis Boyle, the U.S. attorney in North Carolina’s eastern district, said in a statement.

Earlier this year, Boyle’s office also announced the conviction of a 70-year-old Canadian citizen who was sentenced to two months in prison for claiming he was an American and voting in 2022 and 2024.

Historically, though, such prosecutions have a mixed record in court. During President Donald Trump’s first term, dozens more in North Carolina were charged with the same crimes. Of the more than 40 cases prosecutors publicized, none reached a jury, and only a few resulted in prison time, court records show.

The problem with the cases, one civil liberties attorney said, was the facts.

“If we’ve learned anything from how these cases have played out, what we really see is that a very, very small number of people, in good faith, mistakenly register to vote, and occasionally do vote without knowing that what they’re doing is wrong,” Jake Sussman, the chief counsel for justice system reform at the Southern Coalition for Social Justice, told NC Local. 

The U.S. attorneys in the state’s eastern and middle districts did not respond to requests for comment for this story.

U.S. Attorney Russ Ferguson, who oversees federal prosecutors in Charlotte and further west, said in a statement that the public “must have confidence that our elections are conducted fairly and that every ballot cast is a lawful one.”

“Here, after reviewing the relevant evidence, the grand jury found probable cause to charge all the individuals indicted. We are confident in the evidence and will present it in court at trial,” said Ferguson, whose office is prosecuting three people accused of voting as noncitizens.

What’s alleged now

One of the more serious charges some face is that they “knowingly” made a “false statement or claim” that they were “a citizen of the United States in order to register to vote or to vote in any Federal, State, or local election.” Someone convicted of that felony faces up to five years in prison and fines. 

Others were charged with voting by an alien, which carries a sentence of up to a year in prison.

Defendants contacted by NC Local, still early in their cases, were hesitant to speak publicly. But some said their circumstances were more complicated than the indictments suggested. 

One man, 71-year-old Robert Cordett, similarly told WRAL that he was born in Canada but adopted by an American mother and lived in the country for most of his life. He thought he was a dual citizen and voted in American elections five or six times, he said.

Concerns about voter fraud have risen dramatically since Trump falsely claimed that the 2020 presidential election was stolen from him. But evidence continues to show that it is very rare across the country.

Sussman, the Southern Coalition for Social Justice attorney, questioned the recent indictments’ timing. 

“Is this an ongoing, massive problem? Or is this, in a cynical approach, trying to send a message? Is this trying to deter people from voting?” he said in an interview shortly after the charges were filed and days before the midterm elections.

Ferguson, the U.S. attorney in the western district, pushed back against the idea that the indictments were timed. 

“The federal grand jury in the Western District of North Carolina meets each month, and the cases were presented in accordance with that schedule,” he said. 

Past cases ended in dismissals, plea deals

Then-U.S. Attorney Robert Higdon, who oversaw federal prosecutors in the eastern part of the state during Trump’s first term, regularly announced cases in which noncitizens were accused of voting. Other charges were filed and announced in one press release in the state’s middle district.

NC Local compared announcements by both offices during the first Trump administration against court records. Out of those 41 cases:

  • None reached trial. Five were dismissed, and the rest ended in pleas, often in deals with prosecutors.
  • Sixteen defendants were accused of lying about being citizens to vote. But only two, Jorge Alberto Chavez-Moreno and Mokhtar Qaid Ahmed Gulaimid, were found guilty of that crime. Chavez-Moreno was sentenced to six months in prison for it, and convictions for identity theft and fraud-related crimes pushed his total prison time to two years. Gulaimid received two years of probation and $2,100 in fines.
  • Forty people were charged with voting by an alien. That charge was more successful in court — 34 of the 40 pleaded guilty or no contest — but came with lighter sentences. In an outlier case, Ramon Esteban Jaez-Perez was sentenced to serve a year and a day in prison for voting as an alien and for passport fraud. Three others were sentenced to two weeks, a month and four months in prison for the crime. Most people found guilty, however, received probation and/or were ordered to pay a few hundred dollars in fines.

Defendants were at times confused by the events leading up to their charges. 

At Alessandro Cannizzaro’s Oct. 10, 2018, sentencing hearing for his voting by an alien charge, he told U.S. District Judge Terrence Boyle that he came to the country legally in 1985. Cannizzaro said he applied for citizenship in 2003, passed the required test, but was told to come back for his swearing-in “because the rooms were full,” according to a transcript of the hearing.

He called to check on taking the oath, he said, but never heard anything. When his family went to vote, he joined them and never checked his status, he said. 

“So I’m here today to take full responsibility, and I’m deeply sorry,” he told the judge, adding that he would still like to become a citizen.

As Cannizzaro’s attorney, Elliot Abrams, began explaining that Cannizzaro never received a letter informing him of the next step in the process, the judge cut him off.

“I’ll impose a fine of $200,” Boyle said.

Creative Commons License

Republish our articles for free, online or in print, under a Creative Commons license.

Ryan Oehrli is a statewide accountability reporter at NC Local and a Report for America corps member.